Idol Dish

All the Dish that's fit to print about American Idol!

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

The Final Judgement

Seems every new episode of AI6 feels like the first real episode. Tonight was like that again for me. Tonight, going from 40 to 24, the ball moved swiftly and firmly into our court.. and we accept the challenge. We promise to dial and text our little fingers off... Tonight, I'm gonna try to turn a new leaf and focus on the positives... After tonight, it's all up to us.

First Up, Sunjaya Malakar - who sang Some Kind of Wonderful... Unfortunately, his sister didn't make it, and God love him, he shed tears for her. And he made it Through! Sunjaya's smile lights up the world. Let's hope his voice holds true.

Melinda Doolittle - the INCREDIBLE former backup singer... FORMER, being the key word.

Brandon Rodgers - Another FORMER backup singer... Rock it!

I'm thrilled for all the finalists, but I couldn't be any happier for these 2.

Gina Glocksen - Through with flying colors...

Hayley Scarnato - Made it through...

Phil Stacy - He of the outrageous BLUE eyes... who missed the birth of his daughter to audition... Made it!!

Chris Sligh - a physical cross between Meatloaf and Justin Guarini... great personality, terrific voice... and although Simon said he wasn't one of the better singers, He Made it! And I disagree with Simon on this one.

BLAKE Lewis- the myspace favorite by a mile, with a fan club of "Blaker Girls" who even have t-shirts for sale - made it! - but Simon wants to be perfectly clear, this is a singing, not beat boxing, competition.

Paul Kim - "Barefoot Boy" who also has a thing for his "lucky drawers"... made it through!

Jordan Sparks - stunning voice... stunning girl... and so excited she looked like she could burst through her skin.

AJ Tabaros... made it through... sorry, but i don't think he'll be around very long. I know I promised to keep it positive tonight, but this choice didn't make sense to me.

Nicholas Pedro - who blew it during Hollywood week last year, Made it Through.

Lakisha Jones... ok.. I now have a sentimental favorite. No regrets.

6 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

ok, i dont know about the rest of you, but i dont know why sundance made it through. He messed up in Hollywood week every time he went up there, why did they let him through? does he have something on one of the judges or something? i dont understand that at all!!

8:59 PM  
Blogger CarolynBBDish said...

not sure about that Susan, but i'd have to go with that variety headline i mentioned a few posts ago... "cronyism, bias"... I think they're giving him the familial benefit of the doubt.

6:47 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

well, if they are going to do that, then there are so many others that should be there besides the ones that are there like baylie and ebony. they were so much better than half the girls they have now.

9:12 AM  
Blogger CarolynBBDish said...

i was referring to his having a musical heritage... dad was a star.

9:18 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

oh, ok, i guess i didnt really read what you said, sorry

2:19 PM  
Blogger CarolynBBDish said...

alas.. my word is not yet considered gospel. ;)

3:38 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home